info@staffingboutique.org
One Liberty Plaza, 165 Broadway, 23rd Floor New York, NY 10006

Retained Executive Search for the C-Suite

When the seat at the top is empty, everything waits. Funders, staff, boards and students all feel it. Our retained search practice finds CEOs, Executive Directors and C-suite leaders for nonprofits, charter school networks and public agencies, with a dedicated team, a defined process and complete confidentiality.

Retained search is not a resume service. You engage us exclusively, we commit a dedicated team to your search, and we stay with it until the right leader is in the seat.

C‑Suite Roles We Recruit

  • Chief Executive Officers, Presidents and Executive Directors
  • Chief Operating Officers
  • Chief Financial Officers
  • Chief Development and Advancement Officers
  • Chief Program and Chief Impact Officers
  • Chief People Officers and CHROs
  • Chief Academic Officers, charter network CEOs and Heads of School

Our Retained Search Process

  1. Discovery with your board and search committee. We define the role, the culture, the budget and what success looks like in year one, then turn it into a position profile you approve.
  2. Market mapping and direct outreach. The best executives are rarely looking at job boards. We identify and approach proven leaders directly and discreetly.
  3. Rigorous assessment. Structured interviews, leadership and culture fit, and thorough reference checks before anyone reaches your committee.
  4. A curated shortlist. You meet a small group of finalists who are qualified, interested and aligned with your mission.
  5. Offer and transition. We guide the offer, the negotiation and the handoff so your new leader starts strong.
  6. Onboarding support. We check in with you and your new leader through the first months in the role.

Why Retained Search

  • Exclusive focus: a dedicated team on your search, not a race between agencies
  • Confidentiality: essential when you are replacing a sitting executive or leaders are not yet ready to go public
  • Depth: we reach passive candidates who would never answer a posting
  • Board alignment: we keep your search committee informed and moving toward one decision

Why Staffing Boutique

  • Katie Warnock has recruited mission-driven leaders since 2005 and founded Staffing Boutique in 2011
  • Deep experience with boards, search committees and executive transitions
  • 10,000+ placements across nonprofits, charter schools and government agencies
  • Certified Women-Owned Business with NYC, NYS, NJ, Port Authority and SCA certifications
  • Interim leadership coverage available while the search runs

Start a Confidential Conversation

Planning a leadership transition, or already facing one? Talk to us and we will walk you and your board through what a retained search looks like for your organization. Every conversation is confidential.

Keep reading: Nonprofit Executive Search · Direct Hire · Interim and Temporary Staffing